Why Church Matters by Jonathan Wilson - A Literary Review
One of the differences between a literary review and
a straight up book review is that literary reviews are written to help
with future research. So I am writing with the idea that this will
guide me to what I want to go back and study. There are various
approaches to literary reviews, but here will be mine.
LITERARY REVIEW
I basically start with my sense of the author's thesis, followed by a
general overview of the book, and then I focus on themes that are
pertinent to my research. With that said, here is my review.
THESIS
Wilson in Why Church Matters contends that a healthy ecclesiology occurs when the church becomes a participant in God’s work (by God’s grace) by engaging in the practices that witness to the kingdom.
GENERAL OVERVIEW
Wilson begins his book with an explanation of the notion of practice, as developed by Alasdair MacIntyre, and in the three sections of the book, he explains how the body of Christ best embodies these practices. In the first section of this book, Wilson describes what he considers the foundational practice of the church – faithful worship. In the second section, he addresses practices that he judges to be in need of renovation today – witness as kingdom words and deeds and discipleship as human flourishing. And in section three he talks about practices that build on the foundations and renovations and form the church toward the kingdom. These practices include baptism, the Eucharist, foot washing, confessing the creeds and suffering as the Power of the kingdom. In describing each of these practices, Wilson helps the church to live as a faithful witness to the kingdom of God.
THOUGHTS TO CONSIDER
One of the more beneficial chapters of this book occurs when Wilson summarizes MacIntyre’s often quoted book, After Virtue. After MacIntyre analyzes how our culture has been shaped by the Enlightenment project, in his assessment, our culture has abandoned “most convictions about the telos (the “good,” the created purpose) of human life and human activities. This abandonment of telos drains our actions of any real meaning and significance” (14). Wilson then describes MacIntyre’s five ways of understanding of practice, but recasts them in light of Christian tradition, which I outline in the next paragraph. This idea of practice is what Wilson uses to build the rest of his book on.
- Practices embody a concept of the good. Wilson understands the Christian telos to be that the church is to witness to the kingdom by being and making disciples.
- Practices constitute a community. In other words, “the church does not have an identity rooted in something other than its practices” (18).
- Practices are oriented to internal goods. God is not to be followed for some “external” good, like material prosperity or security, rather the good is that the gospel of Christ be made known to those who have yet to hear and believe.
- Practices extend our conceptions of the good. The idea here is that the community of disciples’ conception of the good is transformed by its practices (20).
- Practices enable us to participate in the good. He veers from MacIntrye here, for MacIntrye says practices enable us to achieve the good, but Wilson points out that grace makes us participants in the good, not achievers. Wilson then says that “Practices cannot be sustained apart from institutional structures” (22) and that “the institutions of the church are to serve the practices of the church” (23). Practicing for Wilson is not like basketball practice, but rather like practicing medicine or practicing law.
After fleshing out this idea of practice, he takes each of the practices aforementioned, and looks at them in light of the telos. For example, when he talks about worship, the big question is not “Did I like it?” But rather “Does this worship reflect God’s character and will?” “Is it a foretaste of the coming Kingdom?”
One more note, in the appendix Wilson assesses the ecclesiology of Francis Schaeffer, Chuck Colson, Rick Warren and Brian McLaren. He finds Rick Warren wanting.














Recent Comments